How hard would it be to set up the members profile to look more like a web page? Ad a few more graphics, description, header etc. I know if we had this set up I would make a lot of members happy.

Members could build a mini web page during registration.

You could use the 4 extra custom profile fields to let them add just about anything. What else would you like? The graphics are what you have in your ubb, tho adding more and changing the layout would be a matter of editing the template (public_profile.pl) to how you like it. You can make it a real nice page if you want

To make it exact: it's public_display_profile.pl (and public_my_profile.pl if you want to change this too)