OK, I'll confess I was being deliberately contentious. You are of course quite right. I'm retired now, so I can afford to indulge myself but before then I did honor the guidelines you listed and even now I cross-check a selection of browsers to make sure nobody is missing anything vital. At the WOPR site, which I created and ran for years, I was able to bend the rules to a certain extent because I knew the people who came there were power-users. Funny thing is that even though these were hard-core Microsoft Office users a high percentage of them insisted on using Netscape so I always had the stuggle to maintain compatibility.
However I do think our w3t users should be encouraged to accept (simple) Javascript. At present, we have to insist on them accepting cookies. Neither of these is much of a threat and they allow things nothing else will. We have to be careful that we don't get so hamstrung by legacy setups and legacy mindsets that we cripple our sites unneccessarily when by clever coding we can have it all.
[]
http://www.amdragon.com/images/eileensig.gif[/]