Check my post at infopop - I have a follow up question.
It seems that 3 of your posts aren't displaying... they are replies to anonymous(deleted) users?
That may be the clue to track down the real bug. The redirect thing seemed to fix it - but in your case there should be a page 6 - it's just 3 posts in the middle are not being displayed.... and when page 6 is empty - it directs back to the last page with posts (page 5)