UBB.Developers Forums UBB.classic V6.4 - 6.7 Modifications V6 Mod Ideas Feedback system from USERS.

I run and 3D scifi website (www.scifi-meshes.com) that users post images to and other projects to and try and get feedback from other users as to how to improve apon their work. I recently had a few members express an desire for feedback system. I've not seen anything like this and I just wondered if it's possible:????

They wrote:

This suggestion may quite possibly by straight out impossible -

My suggestion is the implementation of a Feedback type rating system where users can rate the amount and type of feedback they would like on their work.
I think 3 would be enough:

Creative
On a 1-10 scale, the amount of feedback you would like in regards to the creative aspect of your work. Includes originality etc.

Technical
On a 1-10, the amount of feedback in regards to the technical aspect of your work, this means modelling and texturing techinque etc.

Accuracy
For recreated models, ie ST,SW,B5 etc - on a 1-10 of how accurate the model is and how it could be improved.

If anyone knows of such a hack or thinks they can help? I know I'd be interested.

Aceman
[email protected]

Wow, that's a heck of a requirement... Far more than just a simple hack. Statistical magic would be required....

(Side note: I'm surprised that the community was able to come together again after SFA disbanded...)

Aceman, good idea

I think I have made a suggestion that has something in common with your idea here.
Have a look at THIS ONE
I would have been nice to see something like that.
www.sourceforge.net has a system like what I think of in my suggestment....is it something like that you think of?

*******
Actually I now see that it isnt quite the same idea we have, but anyway...good idea

[ July 26, 2001 12:09 PM: Message edited by: kaukagaul ]